|
Post by obobfla on Jan 12, 2018 0:26:44 GMT -5
Since my wife died, the best way to describe the way I feel is raw. I feel like every bandage I ever had has been ripped off me all at once. All emotions are twice as intense, particularly sadness and anger. Because of this, I am finding it harder to filter both my behavior and what I say.
I went to a Grief Support group Monday for the first time. There were only two other people there, a young widow who lost her husband to cancer and the group facilitator. During the session, I mentioned that the grief widows feel is very different than divorce. I shared that my marriage was less than perfect, partly because of the lack of sex. I mentioned that I talked about this in an online Sexless Marriage forum.
Today, I got a call from the facilitator. She said that by bringing up my sexless marriage, I was being inappropriate. She said I should wait for the next group in three months, but in the meantime she would offer me individual therapy until then.
I told her I will get individual therapy, just not from her. If she was bothered about what I said, then I would not want her as a therapist in any way, shape, or form. Having been a support group facilitator, I found it incredulous to tell someone that they could not return to a group for sharing personal information. I have had people say inappropriate things is group before. Neither I nor any other facilitator I know would tell anyone they could not return the next session. I would suggest better places for those people to get help. But if those people felt the group helped them, they were welcome to stay, provided they follow group guidelines. Maybe I am overly sensitive, but I felt like a kid being held back or sent to time out.
I realize that this is a grief group. But it is a grief group for spouses - people who supposed sex partners have died. Part of dealing with grief is dealing with the feelings we had for our spouse, where it is love, anger, or fear. Sex or lack thereof was part of my marriage. It is now part of my grief too.
|
|
|
Post by baza on Jan 12, 2018 1:02:51 GMT -5
I wonder if the young widow had said something on the lines of - "Geez I miss my late husbands dick throbbing deep within me" - if the facilitator would have suggested that was inappropriate ? To me, that would be a perfectly appropriate thing to raise in a group environment. Indeed *anything* relevant to ones grief I think is appropriate. Even - actually especially - those uncharitable thoughts about ones deceased one might have. (in dealing with my grief over my ex missus' passing, I was surprised to find I had a fair bit of anger toward her, which I felt was rather uncharitable on my part and was a bit reticent to talk about) Anyway Brother obobfla , long story short, I think that whatever one is feeling, whatever one wants to talk about, whatever emotions come up are all perfectly legitimate. I think sourcing a different facilitator is a smart move. I am feeling for you at this time. My ex missus died in 2015 (we had been apart 6 years by then, but on pretty good terms) so I won't insult you by saying "I know how you feel" but I will offer you this. . . it does get better.
|
|
|
Post by DryCreek on Jan 12, 2018 1:44:18 GMT -5
obobfla, the facilitator sounds inexperienced or spineless. No doubt, the one other participant made a comment to her, and instead of defending the group as a place of deep honesty, raw emotions, and support she chickened out and threw you under the bus. Regardless of how it might have been better handled, you'll be better off with a different facilitator. Try not to let it eat at you or keep you from getting support.
|
|
|
Post by tamara68 on Jan 12, 2018 5:40:46 GMT -5
obobfla I am very sorry you had this experience. She obviously is incapable of her work. It wouldn't surprise me if the hype around #metoo has influenced ignorant people like her to be negative about everything that has to do with discussing anything sexual. Maybe also the general idea of 'nothing but good about the dead' has been making her feel uncomfortable. Lots of people can't stand things that are different from the most common beliefs and experiences. And there are plenty of therapists that are not very helpful at all. Bad luck to encounter those but I do hope you can find a real support group.
|
|
|
Post by northstarmom on Jan 12, 2018 7:01:20 GMT -5
Your therapist is incompetent and callous. Please support yourself by finding a therapist who understands that upon the death of a partner, grief over the loss of a sex life is normal and appropriate to discuss even if the sex life loss occurred long before the death.
I suspect that the widow in your group was uncomfortable because your words made her feel guilty for denying her husband sex. Another possibility is she feels guilty about missing sex, too..
A NYTimes article from Last year: “After Alice Radosh’s husband of 40 years died in 2013, she received, in addition to the usual condolences, countless offers of help with matters like finances, her car and household repairs. But no one, not even close friends or grief counselors, dared to discuss a nagging need that plagues many older women and men who outlive their sexual partners.
Dr. Radosh, 75 and a neuropsychologist by training, calls it “sexual bereavement,” which she defines as grief associated with losing sexual intimacy with a long-term partner. The result, she and her co-author Linda Simkin wrote in a recently published report, is “disenfranchised grief, a grief that is not openly acknowledged, socially sanctioned and publicly shared.”
“It’s a grief that no one talks about,” Dr. Radosh, a resident of Lake Hill, N.Y., said in an interview. “But if you can’t get past it, it can have negative effects on your physical and emotional health, and you won’t be prepared for the next relationship,” should an opportunity for one come along.
Yes, dear readers of all ages and the children of aging parents, many people in their golden years still have sexual urges and desires for intimacy that go unfulfilled when a partner becomes seriously ill or dies.
Studies have shown that people are still having and enjoying sex in their 60s, 70s and 80s,” Dr. Radosh said. “They consider their sexual relationship to be an extremely important part of their lives. But when one partner dies, it’s over.”
In a study of a representative national sample of 3,005 older American adults, Dr. Stacy Tessler Lindau and co-authors found that 73 percent of those ages 57 to 64, 53 percent of those 65 to 74 and 26 percent of those 75 to 85 were still sexually active.
Yet a report published by the United Kingdom’s Department of Health in 2013, the National Service Framework for Older People, “makes no mention of the problems related to sexual issues older people may face,” Dr. Radosh and Ms. Simkin wrote in the journal Reproductive Health Matters. “Researchers have even suggested that some health care professionals might share the prejudice that sex in older people is ‘disgusting’ or ‘simply funny’ and therefore avoid discussing sexuality with their older patients.”
Dr. Radosh and Ms. Simkin undertook “an exploratory survey of currently married women” that they hope will stimulate further study of sexual bereavement and, more important, reduce the reluctance of both lay people and health professionals to speak openly about this emotionally and physically challenging source of grief.
As one therapist who read their journal article wrote, “Two of my clients have been recently widowed and felt that they were very unusual in ‘missing sex at my age.’ I will use your article as a reference for these women.”
Another wrote: “It got me thinking of ALL the sexual bereavement there is, through being single, through divorce, through disinterest and through what I am experiencing, through prostatectomy. It is not talked about.”
Prior research has “documented that physicians/counselors are generally uncomfortable discussing sex with older women and men,” the researchers noted. “As a result, such discussions either never happen or happen awkwardly.” Even best-selling memoirs about the death of a spouse, like Joan Didion’s “The Year of Magical Thinking,” fail to discuss the loss of sexual intimacy, Dr. Radosh said.
Rather than studying widows, she and Ms. Simkin chose to question a sampling of 104 currently partnered women age 55 and older, lest their research add to the distress of bereaved women by raising a “double taboo of death and sex.” They cited a sarcastic posting from a woman who said she was not a good widow because “a good widow does not crave sex. She certainly doesn’t talk about it…. Apparently, I stink at being a good widow.”
The majority of survey participants said they were currently sexually active, with 86 percent stating that they “enjoyed sex,” the researchers reported. Nearly three in four of the women thought they would miss sex if their partner died, and many said they would want to talk about sex with friends after the death. However, “76 percent said they would want friends to initiate that discussion with them,” rather than bringing it up themselves.
Yet, the researchers found, “even women who said they were comfortable talking about sex reported that it would not occur to them to initiate a discussion about sex if a friend’s partner died.” The older the widowed person, the less likely a friend would be willing to raise the subject of sex. While half of respondents thought they would bring it up with a widowed friend age 40 to 49, only 26 percent would think to discuss it with someone 70 to 79 and only 14 percent if the friend was 80 or older.
But even among young widows, the topic is usually not addressed, said Carole Brody Fleet of Lake Forest, Calif., the author of “Happily Even After” who was widowed at age 40. In an interview she said, “No one brought up my sexuality.” Ms. Fleet, who conducts workshops for widowed people, is forthright in bringing up sex with attendees, some of whom may think they are “terrible people” for even considering it. She cited “one prevailing emotion: Guilt. Widows don’t discuss the loss of sexual intimacy with friends or mental health professionals because they feel like they’re cheating. They think, ‘How can I feel that?’ But you’re not cheating or casting aspersions on your love for the partner who died.
“You can honor your past, treasure it, but you do not have to live in your past. It’s not an either-or situation. You can incorporate your previous life into the life you’re moving into. People have an endless capacity to love.”
However, Ms. Fleet, who remarried nine years after her husband died, cautioned against acting precipitously when grieving the loss of sexual intimacy. “When you’re missing physical connection with another person, you can make decisions that are not always in your best interest,” she said. “Sex can cloud one’s judgment. Maybe you’re just missing that. It helps to take sex out of the equation and reassess the relationship before becoming sexually intimate.”
Dr. Radosh urges the widowed to bring up grief over the loss of sexual intimacy with a therapist or in a bereavement group. She said, “Even if done awkwardly, make it part of the conversation. Let close friends know this is something you want to talk about. There is a need to normalize this topic.”‘
|
|
|
Post by WindSister on Jan 12, 2018 9:59:57 GMT -5
Wow. That was cold. I hope you can find a better group and therapist soon.
As a therapist, she should realize that everyone is raw in those settings. Being in a raw state, some can't handle comments from others at all (we see that sometimes here, too, someone goes off on others because they are being triggered in their raw state). If the other participant complained to the facilitator, she should have counselled that individual, not ban you!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 12, 2018 11:32:26 GMT -5
obobfla, I’ll keep this short: You’re right and that grief counselor is wrong. I would definitely advise getting help from someone else. Preferable a person who has been married or in a serious relationship him- or herself. There’s probably no way to check this. But when I was in my 20s, technically an adult, I had no clue about some of the complexities and emotions involved in serious partnerships.
|
|
|
Post by GeekGoddess on Jan 12, 2018 21:21:55 GMT -5
I’m amazed at this. The leader person really ought to have said something in the group setting if you were somehow covering a topic “not allowed” for discussion. If you were within allowable topics, & the widow complained after the meeting- the leader should have explained to her that open & honest sharing was allowed & needs to be respected. If the leader was going to “kick you out” of the group, they may ethically offer a referral but really shouldn’t be offering their own personal services as therapist. There is just SO MUCH wrong with this scenario. And none of what I see as wrong was with you, obobfla, or with what you shared. I’m sorry you had this happen. You definitely will find better support elsewhere.
|
|
|
Post by northstarmom on Jan 13, 2018 8:13:50 GMT -5
If the group was inappropriate for someone the person who needed individual therapy instead was the widow who became unglued because sex and anger were talked about. Many people including those whose marriages were happy get angry at a partner who died. Many widows and widowers miss sex since sex is a normal and expected part of most committed relationships.
The therapist dropped the ball. Big time. The therapist was not the right one for you. I hope you will find and use the services of a more insightful therapist. A good therapist would have the insight to be able to be of good support through individual therapy. The person needn’t be of mature age to know that for most adults, missing sex is part of the grief of the end of a long term romantic relationship or marriage.
|
|
|
Post by petrushka on Jan 13, 2018 19:34:28 GMT -5
First, I wonder why some of my fellow iliasmers are blaming the poor widow for the idiot counselor's retarded attitudes. We don't know jack shit about that. So stop laying blame at her feet.
Of course the sexless marriage is a MAJOR issue here in your situation Bob. It makes the whole scenario with the grieving process so much more complicated, and so much more ambivalent. I totally can empathise, having been in a similar situation once. Just like I would grieve over the loss of my flatmate, I am grieving over the loss of 20 years that she took away from me. Cheated me out of. All that passion burning my heart, with no target. In a way. If that 20 years had been gloriously happy - grief would be so much more straight-forward. The feelings so much less ambivalent. Instead, there's relief mixed in, historic anger, frustration, guilt (for not just feeling entirely grief stricken, maybe) ...
I know I am entirely responsible for my choices, but if my wife were to fall under a bus tomorrow, there would be a veritable jumble of emotions to go through for me, including all of the above. Not just the despair at having lost one deeply beloved.
I agree with others, and with what you said: kick that ignorant cow to the curb, and find a counselor/therapist who actually has your interests as their concern. Maybe she should to work with pre-schoolers relating to iphone addiction, that might be safe enough for her. As it happens I have observed this before: some people attracted to grief counseling are actually vultures, ghouls, and spiritual predators. People with an AGENDA. People who sense they might have easy game to exert influence over. I've met a few like that.
And: condolences Bob, and all the best.
|
|
|
Post by shamwow on Jan 16, 2018 8:11:00 GMT -5
Since my wife died, the best way to describe the way I feel is raw. I feel like every bandage I ever had has been ripped off me all at once. All emotions are twice as intense, particularly sadness and anger. Because of this, I am finding it harder to filter both my behavior and what I say. I went to a Grief Support group Monday for the first time. There were only two other people there, a young widow who lost her husband to cancer and the group facilitator. During the session, I mentioned that the grief widows feel is very different than divorce. I shared that my marriage was less than perfect, partly because of the lack of sex. I mentioned that I talked about this in an online Sexless Marriage forum. Today, I got a call from the facilitator. She said that by bringing up my sexless marriage, I was being inappropriate. She said I should wait for the next group in three months, but in the meantime she would offer me individual therapy until then. I told her I will get individual therapy, just not from her. If she was bothered about what I said, then I would not want her as a therapist in any way, shape, or form. Having been a support group facilitator, I found it incredulous to tell someone that they could not return to a group for sharing personal information. I have had people say inappropriate things is group before. Neither I nor any other facilitator I know would tell anyone they could not return the next session. I would suggest better places for those people to get help. But if those people felt the group helped them, they were welcome to stay, provided they follow group guidelines. Maybe I am overly sensitive, but I felt like a kid being held back or sent to time out. I realize that this is a grief group. But it is a grief group for spouses - people who supposed sex partners have died. Part of dealing with grief is dealing with the feelings we had for our spouse, where it is love, anger, or fear. Sex or lack thereof was part of my marriage. It is now part of my grief too. Did she say EXACTLY how you had been inappropriate? For example, in AA, we are encouraged to keep our discussions focused on alcohol and how it affects our lives. If someone takes their opportunity to share and then goes on about how Donald Trump is a demon / Saint that would be inappropriate. This forum discourages talk about politics and such since it isn't part of the SM issue necessarily. You feel grief that your wife died. You also feel anger and resentment. If the facilitator doesn't get that or can't handle it? You are right to go elsewhere.
|
|